Savings & Discounts

These are the Best Pies in NYC for Thanksgiving (and Beyond)

There's one dessert on everyone’s mind as Thanksgiving approaches: pie! From peanut butter chocolate pie to plum crumble to sugar-free options, these great NYC spots are waiting to take your holiday dessert to the next level.

Where to Get Pie in NYC: Midtown West

pie

At Trademark Taste + Grind the pies aren't just delicious but unique as well. Elevate your Thanksgiving with a nontraditional pie like the Tiramisu Icebox Pie. The Tiramisu pie has a classic Tiramisu flavor paired with Trademark cold brew custard! 38 W. 36th., ingoodcompany.com

Where to Get Pie in NYC: Chelsea

Pie by Billy's Pie

When you're in the mood for a full, decadent pie, Billy’s Bakery is the spot for you! With locations in Chelsea, Tribeca, The Plaza Food Hall, and an Upper West Side storefront, you're never too far away from your next apple crumb pie or banana cream. If you ask us, we're partial to their special peanut butter chocolate pie, which pairs perfectly with a nice refreshing glass of milk. Orders@billysbakerynyc.com, billysbakerynyc.com

Where to Get Pie in NYC: Williamsburg

Blue Stove Pie

The Blue Stove is bringing back handmade small-batch pies to the city. From pear ginger crisp and plum crumble to Thanksgiving pie specials, there are lots of original options to choose from. They only require 24 hours notice for most pie orders, but due to Thanksgiving, any pies for holiday pickup need to be ordered by Friday, November 16th. 415 Graham Ave., 718-766-7419, thebluestove.com

Where to Get Pie in NYC: Gowanus

Four & Twenty Blackbirds is an amazing place to get pies in NYC. They wrote the book on pie…literally! Order a whole pie or pie by the slice, where it's available on a first-come,  first-served basis. To order a whole pie call by noon to guarantee next day pick-up. We suggest trying their lemon chess pie for a perfect citrus explosion of flavor! 439 Third Ave., 718-499-2917, birdsblack.com

Where to Get Pie in NYC: Upper East Side 

Close up pie

For pies, cakes, and cupcakes a NYC go-to is Two Little Red Hens. Two Little Red Hens serves up amazing 10-inch pies daily in their bakery. Their traditional pies (pumpkin, apple, and pecan/chocolate pecan pie) are simply delicious. 1652 Second Ave., 212-452-0476, twolittleredhens.com 

Where to Get Pie in NYC: SoHo

The Dutch might be a restaurant but they are known for their desserts…especially pie! Stop by for a midday meal and make sure to order a slice for dessert. We suggest taking a bite out of their black bottom pecan pie or their pear and ginger crumble pie, each slice tastes like Thanksgiving spirit! 131 Sullivan St., 212-677-6200, thedutchnyc.com

Where to Get Pie in NYC: Lower East Side

Petee's Pies random pies

With the freshest ingredients sourced locally, and vegan and gluten-free options, Petee’s Pies can be enjoyed by all. Petee’s Pie Company serves up 9-inch pies that are made from scratch, with grassfed butter and organic NY state flour used in the delicious crust. We suggest their Lavish Chocolate Cream Pie, which features real gold leaf-topped chocolate flakes or stepping outside the box and ordering their Chicken potpie. Text them to order! 61 Delancey St., 646-494-3630, peteespie.com

Where to Get Pie in NYC: Hell’s Kitchen 

Fall Sampler

Established in 1985, Little Pie Company has been a trailblazer in the NYC pie industry for seasonal and year-round fans alike. They even offer a pie sampler so you can try four small, 5-inch pies (sour cream apple walnut pie, Southern pecan pie, Mississippi mud pie and pumpkin pie) instead of committing to the full thing. They even have a Thanksgiving special menu that features a sugarless version of a true classic. The Little Pie Company also delivers around NYC so you can order online or pick up your order and cut down on the hassle. 424 W. 43rd St., 212-736-4780, littlepiecompany.com

About the Author

Samantha is a New York native; she was born and raised on Long Island. Samantha is a graduate of Fordham University, having received her BA in communications.

Bringing a group to NYC? Free planning services

Let us know what you are looking for and we will try to connect you directly and get discounts.

Enter the code: 3972

More Articles